Ayurveda and Modern Medicine
Dr. Harbans Singh Wasir, MD, DM, FAMS,
Professor and head of Department of Cardiology,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi.
Disease-free condition is the best source of virtue, wealth, gratification
and emancipation, while the diseases are destroyers of this (source),
welfare and life itself
Charaka Samhita 4: 15-16
Unlike the various systems of medicine, like allopathy or homeopathy,
Ayurveda is not a system of medicine but a science of life and longevity
(Ayurveda= ayus: age, life, longevity, and veda: knowledge). The concept
of Ayurveda is based on a combined study of body (sharira), sense organs
(indriyas), mind (manas) and soul (atman). Equilibrium of these is related
to health and their dysfunction is equated with death. Homeo-stasis of
the internal milcu (dhatusamaya), or equilibrium of the various dhatus,
is considered essential for absence of disease. The modern definition
of health according to the World Health Organization (WHO) is 'the state
of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing and not necessarily
the absence of disease and infirmity'.
Ayurveda defines health as:
Abnormality (disorder) is disequilibrium of the dhatus and their
equilibrium is normalcy (health) . Health is known as happiness while
disorder is unhappiness (4)
Knowledge of Ayurveda is eternal, starting with creation; we do not know
when it was not there. The origin of disease and disability must have
been about the same time as the origin of life itself. The fight between
the disease-creating elements and the disease-curing or disease-preventing
systems must have been going on since Lord Brahma's day, as Brahma is
considered to be the creator of the universe. The exact origin of Ayurveda
cannot be dated precisely, but the original text is believed to have been
written in ten million verses in one thousand chapters. The knowledge
of Ayurveda then gradually descended through several sages, including
Bharadwaja, Aitreya, Agnivastha, and finally Charaka and his students
who compiled the text known as Charaka Samhita, which dates between 600
and 1000 B.C.
Charaka's description of Ayurveda is very systematic and in many ways
it surpasses the modern system of medicine, because Ayurveda has a health-oriented
approach, while modern medicine has largely had a disease-oriented approach.
Modern medicine is only now stressing to some extent the role of mind
in health and disease while in Ayurveda the basic approach incorporates
body (sharira), mind (manas) and soul (atman).
Although the Rigveda and Atharvaveda are regarded as great treatises,
Ayurveda is considered to be higher as it deals with life, health and
longevity, and it is through the healthy body only that one can achieve
all righteous tasks in life:
The approach in Ayurveda is wide and wholesome (holistic), while in modern
medicine it is largely limited and materialistic (quick relief from disease
and not much emphasis on promotive or positive health of mind and body).
The mistake often made is when we equate Ayurveda with ayurvedic medicines.
Although Ayurveda lays emphasis on both the preventive and curative aspects,
its stronghold has been the former, its is clearly enunciated by Charaka.
Therapeutics of two types have been described in the ancient Indian literature:
Therapeutics are of two hypes: (1) that which promotes strength.
in the healthy (prevention of disease), and (2) that which alleviates
disorders.
Charaka Samhita 3:4
One of the lengthiest chapters in Charaka Samhita is on longevity and
the role of promotive health care:
From promotive treatment, one attains longevity, memory, intelligence,
freedom from disorders, youthful age, excellence of lustre, complexion
and voice, optimum strength of physique and sense organs, successful
words, respectability and brilliance. Rasayana (promotive treatment)
means the way to attain an excellent life.
Charaka Samhita 4: 7.8
Ayurveda is not just another system of medicine, but a science of total
health care based on the strong pillars of positive health incorporating
the role of the following four aspects: (i) character - achaar, (ii) thought
or mind - vichaar, (iii) interpersonal relations - vyavahaar. and (iv)
diet - altar.
Mind self and body these three make a tripod on which the living
world stands The (living body) is purusha (person) sentient and location
of this Veda (4yurveda). For him alone, this Veda is brought to light.
Charaka Samhita 6: 46-47
Charaka Samhita is the most complete text on health care and longevity,
i.e. the Ayurveda contemporary surgical text has been dealt with separately
in the Sushruta Samhita. A Charaka Club was established in New York in
1898, to honour the great Indian physician. Persian and Arabic translators
of the Charaka Samhita had appeared in the 10th century A.D., and a first
English translation appeared in the 19th century. Compared to the biblical
human lifespan of 70 years (three score and ten), Ayurveda's figure for
the human lifespan was given as 100 years, which was divided into four
ashrams or phases of life: (i) brahmacharya: up to 25 years, (ii) grihastha:
25-50 years, (iii) vanaprastha: 50-75 years, and (iv) sannyasa: 75-100
years.
Charaka Samhita Contributions
The ten commandments propounded by Charaka for the study and advancement
of medicine are as follows:
1. Advancement of basic concepts of life: physiological and pathological
phenomena; dhatusamay - equilibrium of dhatus, homeostasis.
2. Rational attitude: treatment with knowledge and practical skills,
not with blind belief. rukti (rational) approach was recommended instead
of daivya (supernatural) therapy. The wise man, desiring health and
long life, should not take any medicine prescribed by irrational physicians.
3. Organisation of symposium: presentation of works/papers on therapy.
Lord Aitreya has been mentioned as presiding over one such meeting.
4. Psychosomatic approach: deha manasa (psycho-somatic) concepts of
disease treatment of the purusha (person) were stressed instead of organic
systems.
5 Individual constitution prakriti (individual psyche/nature) was considered
important in the prescript ion of medicines; basis of anaphylaxis allergy
idiosyncrasy.
6. Expansion of discipline: (i) nidana - etiology, (ii) samprapti -
pathologenesis, (iii) purvarupa - prodroma, (iv) rupa - signs and symptoms,
and (v) upasaya - therapeutics.
7. Scientific method of diagnosis: first study the patient, then study
the suitable drug, and watch for interactions, results and side effects.
8. Importance of nature: drugs and dietetic measures used to aid nature
to fight/prevent disease:
swanbhavoparama - recession of disease by nature.
9. Emphasis on promotive and preventive aspects: Charaka Samhita starts
its first chapter on the longevity of life in which the practice of
rasayana (promotive health care) , aachar (conduct) and lifestyle are
given importance.
10. Scientific study of drugs: analytical study of medicinal plants
in the vedic period. The Rigveda and Atharvaveda mention aushadhi sukta
drugs which are divided into 50 groups, according to their pharmacological
action, based on: rasa, guna, virya, vipatka and prabhava (effects).
Charaka's quadruple
Fully realising the importance and contribution of the physician, the
attendant (nurse), the patient and the drug, in the treatment of the sick,
Charaka defined all the four as follows:
Physician, drug, attendant and patient, this is the quadruple which,
if endowed with proper qualities, leads to time alleviation of disorders
(3)
Physician:
Excellence in theoretical knowledge, experience, dexterity and cleanliness
- this qualities of a physician. (6)
Attendant (nurse):
Knowledge of attendance, dexterity, loyalty and cleanliness:
these are the four qualities of an attendant. (8)
Patient:
Memory, obedience. fearlessness and providing all information about
time disorder - these are the qualities of a patient (9)
Drug:
Abundance, effectively, various pharmaceutical forms and normal composition
- these are the four qualities of drugs. (7)
Employment of all the excellent four - physician, attendant, patient
and drug. in case of disorder of the dhatus, with the object of (re-establishing)
their equilibrium, is said to be therapeutics. (5)
Preventive approach to positive health
This is only a glimpse of what Ayurveda offers, and if this is what Ayurveda
is, then it certainly is much more than just a system of medicine. Dr.
Dean Ornish, a well-known American cardiologist, has recently propounded
that it is possible to reverse atherosclerosis (narrowing of the blood
vessels) by the following regime:
1. Balanced diet, consisting mainly of vegetables and fruits;
2. Regular physical exercise, and
3. Practice of mental relaxation through Yoga and meditation.
This approach may be new for the Americans, but it is certainly not new
for India, where Ayurveda has described three types o diet: sattwic, rajasic
and tamasic. The sattwic diet, containing fresh fruits, vegetables, honey,
curd etc., is considered to be superior. The rajasic diet was prescribed
for those engaged in heavy physical work, and it contains high protein
foods such as various types of meats, beans etc. The tamasic diet which
contains highly spiced and refined foods was considered to be harmful
to the health. Regular, moderate physical exercise and practice of Yoga
are of course mentioned repeatedly in Ayurveda as the essential components
of the preventative approach to positive health.
The major thrust in Ayurveda is on prevention of disease through diet,
physical exercise and Yoga which includes several ways of mental relaxation.
Drugs prepared from herbs, plants and animal products, including the milk
of various animals, ghee and honey, have been used in Ayurveda for the
treatment of different diseases. In the chapter on heart disease, the
Charaka Samhita mentions at several places the reasons for cardiac problems
and the means of prevention.
Cardiac disease of the kapha is born from the intake of fatty meals,
overeating, and also from excessive indulgence in sleep, sedentary habits
and carelessness.
Even wholesome food taken in proper quantity does not get digested
due to anxiety, grief, fear, anger, uncomfortable bed and vigil.
Charaka Samhita 311 :9
The person desiring to protect himself from adverse ejects upon
the heart) coronary blood vessels and the contents thereof should particularly
avoid all the causes of mental affliction.
Charaka Samhita 30:53
In the present times, most deaths and disabilities occur from diseases
of the cardiovascular system, cancer, psychosomatic problems, degenerative
disorders like diabetes, gout and the modern scourge of AIDS. There is
no permanent cure for any of these diseases, and their palliative treatment
is becoming very expensive, which many families and even some states cannot
afford. Modern medicine has provided excellent tertiary care treatment
in the form of very effective drugs, angioplasty procedures, radiotherapy
and sophisticated advanced surgical techniques to tackle some of these
diseases where treatment could be beneficial for variable lengths of time.
There is, therefore, an urgent need on a global level, and more so in
the poor nations, to evolve preventive strategies on a war footing, to
contain the emergence of epidemics of coronary disease, cancer and AIDS.
Concepts and ways and means, as enunciated in Ayurveda, should be revived
to supplement and augment the achievements of modern medicine.
As a city manager is cautious in the duties of the city and a charioteer
in those of time chariot, a wise person should be cautious in the duties
relating to his own body. An axle fitted in a vehicle which is endowed
with all the essential qualities, carries on and perishes with time by
depreciation of its normal limit.
Similarly, the lifespan of the body of a person comes to an end
after the normal limit Such death is known as timely. Just as the same
axle gets destroyed on the way, due to overload, uneven road, want of
road, breaking of wheels, defects in the vehicle or driver, separation
of the bolt, lack of lubrication, and throwing about, similarly, the
lifespan of a person comes to an end in the middle due to over exertion,
diet which is not in accordance with one's nature, and irregular meals
Samhita, sixth century B. C.
|